What does your brand promise depend on?

Covid and a stranded container ship reminded businesses how much their operations depend on events elsewhere. New Zealand’s reliance on imported fuels brings that exposure into focus. But recognising a risk does not necessarily change the decisions that sustain it. For business leaders, the question is whether their promises to customers depend on conditions they cannot control—and what they can do now to preserve their ability to deliver.

Remember the toilet paper?

An everyday commodity suddenly became something worth filling a trolley with. Apparently, preparing for uncertainty required rather more rolls than usual. Buying extra “in case” helped create the empty shelves everyone was worried about.

New Zealand was making toilet paper locally. The problem, supermarkets explained, was getting it onto shelves quickly enough to match the surge in buying. Domestic production helped, but it did not remove the effects of behaviour and distribution. [1]

Then, in March 2021, the Ever Given blocked the Suez Canal for six days. One ship, in one place, disrupted a network serving businesses around the world. UNCTAD reported another surge in container freight rates, adding pressure to supply chains already strained by Covid. [2, 3]

Different events, with a common reminder: what seems dependable in ordinary conditions can become surprisingly fragile when those conditions change.

New Zealand’s energy system offers another example. Renewable sources supplied a record 47.7% of total primary energy in 2025. Yet since refining at Marsden Point ceased in 2022, our petrol, diesel and jet fuel requirements have been supplied through imports of refined products. Our renewable strengths coexist with substantial dependence elsewhere. [4, 5]

Follow those fuels into farm machinery, food distribution and freight, and energy security becomes a question about what our productive economy can keep doing through disruption. Add agricultural inputs and processing, and the connections extend further.

Have we considered New Zealand’s energy, agricultural inputs, freight and food production as one interconnected resilience system—or mainly as separate policy responsibilities?

That question should not presume the risks have been ignored. New Zealand has a Fuel Security Plan, and its 2025 Fuel Security Study found the fuel system largely resilient while identifying improvements. Work is also under way to strengthen critical supply chains. [6, 7]

Importing is not inherently unwise, and producing something locally does not automatically make its supply resilient. Trade gives a small country access to capabilities it could not sensibly reproduce. Local alternatives carry costs and dependencies too.

We can nevertheless continue importing what we need, but it is also imperative that where certain imports are critical to keeping our own economic and production engines running, and where they could become subject to geopolitical pressure, we should look to develop alternatives, reducing demand where practical, diversifying supply and preparing for interruptions. Those choices need to be explicit, and deserve consideration together.

For anyone responsible for a brand, there is a direct commercial consequence. A brand promise depends on capabilities and dependencies the customer never sees.

Reliable delivery, consistent quality, availability and dependable service may be central to why customers choose you. Those commitments rest on suppliers, transport, energy, people and infrastructure, often things you have no direct control over. Disruption somewhere in that network can result in a disappointed customer—and eventually a question about whether your business can be trusted to deliver.

Communications matter when things go wrong. Preparedness shapes what there is to communicate.

This is where scenario planning can earn its place. It needn’t predict the next pandemic or stranded ship. It can explore what happens if a critical input is unavailable for several weeks, delivery times double, or several costs rise together. Which promises could you still honour? Where would you have options? What would you wish you had done sooner?

You cannot control geopolitics or global shipping. You can examine your dependencies, develop contingencies and decide which alternatives are worth investing in before they become urgent.

Perhaps the uncomfortable question is whether we acknowledge that disruption is possible while continuing to make decisions that assume continuity.

When did you last test the conditions your brand promise depends on—and what did that change?

Sources

Numbered references correspond to the evidence cited in the article.

[1] Countdown update 19 March 2020 — Supermarket News Open source

[2] UNCTAD — Review of Maritime Transport 2022 facts and figures on Africa Open source

[3] UNCTAD — Shipping during COVID 19 Why container freight rates have surged Open source

[4] MBIE — Energy in New Zealand 2026 Renewables Open source

[5] MBIE — Energy in New Zealand 2025 Open source

[6] MBIE — Fuel Security Plan Plan on a page Open source

[7] MBIE — Critical supply chains Open source



Brand strategy

Resilience and hidden dependencies